LLenny's Podcast
← All episodes
Carole Robin (Stanford GSB professor, “Touchy Feely”)25 April 2024

How to build deeper, more robust relationships

8Frameworks
15Insights

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster40:30

Feedback Doesn't Ruin Relationships — Bad Feedback Does

Everyone says they want more feedback, yet everyone also believes giving it will damage the relationship, because they've mostly seen it done badly. Carole reframes: feedback doesn't ruin relationships; feedback the way you've usually seen it done ruins relationships. Done well, it actually builds them.

  • People simultaneously crave feedback and fear giving it
  • The belief comes from experiencing feedback given poorly
  • It's the bad delivery, not feedback itself, that harms relationships
  • Feedback given because you're invested in the person strengthens the bond

everybody believes that giving feedback is going to create a problem

Carole Robin · 40:30

feedback the way you've always seen it done or done it ruins relationships

Carole Robin · 41:00
#feedback#relationships#mental-models

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take27:00

A Willingness to Be Vulnerable Makes You a Stronger Leader

Carole names this as one of her genuinely contrarian views: leaders are socialized to hide feelings, but a leader willing to be appropriately vulnerable is more influential, not less. You cannot inspire, motivate, or be seen as a real person while acting like a robot.

  • Leaders were long taught to leave feelings in the parking lot
  • You can't inspire or motivate anyone while showing no feelings
  • Appropriate vulnerability increases a leader's influence
  • People will follow a robotic leader only until they get another option

I actually think that a leader who is willing to be appropriately vulnerable is a stronger leader

Carole Robin · 27:30
#vulnerability#leadership#influence
Hot Take1:11:00

Giving Advice Hinders Relationships — Be a Thought Partner

Leaders hold a mental model that they must have all the answers, but handing out advice widens the power gap and makes people dependent. Carole argues a leader's job is to ensure the best answer is found — from anywhere — and to turn people into problem-solvers, not to keep answering for them. Before giving advice, ask who you're really doing it for.

  • The belief that leaders must have all answers is an unproductive mental model
  • Advice widens power differentials and breeds dependence
  • Being a thought partner develops people and reduces your own workload
  • Ask whether you're advising to puff yourself up or to genuinely help

who am I doing this for am I doing this for me

Carole Robin · 1:12:00

my job isn't just to give you the answers my job is to turn you into somebody who eventually will just know what the right…

Carole Robin · 1:13:30
#advice#leadership#coaching#management

Explainer· 2

Explainer24:30

Appropriate Vulnerability Isn't Dumping Your Panic on the Team

Carole distinguishes appropriate vulnerability from inappropriate over-sharing. Telling the troops you have no idea what you're doing and maybe shouldn't have the job is vulnerable but not appropriate; pretending nothing is wrong also fails. The move is to name the hard reality honestly while still owning the mission and needing your people.

  • Vulnerable disclosure and appropriate vulnerability are not the same thing
  • Admitting you're worthless at the job kills credibility, not builds it
  • Pretending nothing is wrong also destroys credibility
  • Name the problem honestly, admit you don't have the answer, and say you need the team

I wish I could stand up here and tell you I know exactly what's happening and I know exactly what we should do about it…

Carole Robin · 25:30
#vulnerability#leadership#communication
Explainer1:02:00

You Can Change Your Behavior, Not Your Personality

Carole draws a hard line: we're born wired with our personalities and can't change them, but we all have control over our behavior. When someone says "I can't" change a behavior, she'll accept "I don't want to" but not "I can't" — she asks them to own that it's a choice.

  • Personality is innate and fixed; behavior is within our control
  • Extroversion is her wiring, but zipping it was a behavior she learned
  • "I can't" about a behavior is really "I won't"
  • Owning it as a choice is the first step to changing it

we are all capable of changing our Behavior we cannot change our personality we are born wired with personalities

Carole Robin · 1:02:00

but I don't have to accept I can't so I'd just like you to own the fact that it's a choice that you're making

Carole Robin · 1:03:00
#behavior-change#self-awareness#growth

Story· 3

Story27:30

"Are You Human After All?" — The Day Carole Became a Leader

As the first woman in a non-clerical job at a 1975 industrial automation company, Carole had trained herself to leave all feelings in the parking lot. Ten years later, running a $50M region, she got excited about an idea, was met with silence, and started to tear up. A colleague asked if she was human after all — she burst out crying, tore up the agenda, and spent two days with her team talking about who they were. She credits that day as the day she became a leader.

  • She was the first woman in a non-clerical role at the company in 1975
  • She had become expert at suppressing feelings at work
  • Showing emotion unexpectedly deepened her team's loyalty
  • She marks that moment as when she truly became a leader

and then he says are you human after all are you human after all

Carole Robin · 29:00

to this day I believe that was the day I became a leader

Carole Robin · 29:00
#vulnerability#leadership#story
Story33:30

The Furious Manager Who Led With Fear Instead of Anger

A former Leaders in Tech fellow spent a weekend enraged after learning his team missed a major deadline, ready to fire everyone. On Sunday he remembered that anger is often a secondary emotion masking fear, and realized he was actually scared no one else cared as much as he did. Instead of blasting the team on Monday, he told them he was worried and afraid — and they rallied to fix it faster than ever.

  • He was prepared to fire the whole team out of fury
  • He recognized his anger was really fear underneath
  • He opened the meeting by naming the fear, not the anger
  • Leading with the underlying emotion made the team rally instead of defend

so gang I am deeply worried and afraid that I'm the only person here who is as concerned about this miss deadline as I am

Carole Robin · 34:30

I have never had my troops rally to fix something faster

Carole Robin · 34:30
#emotions#feedback#leadership#story
Story52:30

How One Unspoken Grievance Becomes a Ruined Reputation

While teaching in a clock-less law school lecture hall, Carole glanced at her watch to check the time as a student answered. He told her afterward he felt disrespected — and she hugged him for it. Her point: if he'd stayed quiet and instead told others she was disrespectful, an entire reputation would have formed from a moment no one would ever have corrected.

  • She glanced at her watch only to track time, not to dismiss the student
  • The student risked telling her he felt disrespected
  • Direct feedback let her fix a false impression on the spot
  • Unspoken grievances spread to others and calcify into reputation

looked at your watch while I was answering I hugged him

Carole Robin · 53:00

but my reputation is that I don't respect students that's how stuff gets out of control

Carole Robin · 53:30
#feedback#reputation#story

Tool· 1

Tool1:01:30

Carol Dweck's "Mindset" and the Power of "Yet"

Carole recommends Carol Dweck's book Mindset. Her favorite takeaway: adding the word "yet" to a fixed statement instantly updates the mental model behind it — "I don't know how" becomes "I don't know how yet."

  • Recommended book: Mindset by Carol Dweck
  • Adding "yet" reframes a fixed-mindset statement into a growth one
  • "I don't know how" becomes "I don't know how yet"
  • It's an instant update of a limiting mental model

you put a word yet at the end of any of those I don't know how yet I'm not like that yet

Carole Robin · 1:01:30
#books#growth-mindset#mental-models

Takeaway· 6

Takeaway31:00

Feelings Give Meaning to Facts

Being known isn't just sharing facts — feelings are what give facts meaning. Saying "I went ziplining" tells someone little; saying you went terrified because you felt pressured by family and didn't want to be left behind reveals far more of who you are.

  • Facts alone reveal little about a person
  • Adding the feeling behind a fact makes you genuinely known
  • Disclosure works because it lets others attach real meaning to what you share

feelings give meaning to facts

Carole Robin · 31:00

well you learned a lot more about me didn't you

Carole Robin · 31:30
#disclosure#feelings#connection
Takeaway35:00

Anger Is a Secondary Emotion — Underneath Is Fear or Hurt

Carole explains that anger is usually a secondary emotion covering fear or hurt, and that we lead with it because anger feels safe while naming fear or hurt feels vulnerable. Crucially, anger is a distancing emotion, whereas hurt, fear, sadness, and joy are connecting emotions.

  • Anger typically masks an underlying fear or hurt
  • We default to anger because it doesn't make us feel vulnerable
  • Anger pushes people away — it's a distancing emotion
  • Hurt, fear, sadness, loneliness, and joy are connecting emotions

anger is a distancing emotion whereas hurt fear sadness loneliness Happiness joy are all connecting emotions

Carole Robin · 35:30
#emotions#vulnerability#relationships
Takeaway37:00

The Beliefs That Saved You Early Will Cost You Later

We form mental models early in our careers that serve us well at first, then quietly start costing us because we never update them. Carole's rule to never show feelings helped her rise early, then over-served her — but she never noticed the price she was paying to keep believing it.

  • Mental models form early and become deeply grooved
  • A belief can genuinely serve you at one stage of your career
  • The same belief later over-serves and starts costing you
  • We rarely update them because we don't notice the cost we're paying

and then it started it over served me and then it cost me cuz I never had a reason to update it

Carole Robin · 37:30
#mental-models#growth#self-awareness
Takeaway1:00:30

Ask What, When, Where, How — Stay Away From Why

In the art of inquiry, the form of the question decides whether you learn or trigger defensiveness. Yes/no questions are limiting, and questions starting with "why" (why did you do that, why are you crying) provoke defense. Questions that start with what, when, where, and how open up genuine exploration.

  • Yes/no questions are limiting and unproductive
  • "Why" questions reliably trigger defensiveness
  • What, when, where, and how questions invite real exploration
  • Inquiry requires suspending judgment long enough to actually learn

questions that start with why why did you do that are going to make defensive or worse

Carole Robin · 1:00:00

what when where how stay away from why

Carole Robin · 1:01:00
#inquiry#questions#communication
Takeaway1:05:00

When It Goes Sideways, Ask "What Did You Hear Me Say?"

When someone reacts in a way wildly out of proportion to what you actually said, the most powerful repair move is to ask what they heard — because nine times out of ten it isn't what you said. Carole's kitchen example: her offer to help was heard as "you don't know what you're doing," and asking surfaced the gap instead of escalating it.

  • Unexpected reactions usually come from a misheard message
  • Asking "what did you hear me say?" surfaces the real gap
  • Nine times out of ten what they heard isn't what you said
  • This is a core repair skill for when interactions go wrong

go back to what did you hear me say because nine times out of 10 what they heard is not what you said

Carole Robin · 1:05:30
#repair#communication#conflict
Takeaway1:24:30

In the Absence of Data, People Make Things Up

People need to make sense of things, so when they lack information about you they invent it — and connect the dots however they want. The remedy is to disclose more, which gives you more control over your own narrative rather than less.

  • People fill information gaps by making things up
  • They'll connect the dots their own way unless you help them
  • Disclosing more gives you more control over how you're perceived
  • It's another practical case for self-disclosure

in the absence of data people make up so if you don't want people to make up about you you're better off disclosing more

Carole Robin · 1:24:30
#disclosure#perception#communication