LLenny's Podcast
← All episodes
02 February 2025

Tobi Lütke’s leadership playbook: Playing infinite games, operating from first principles, and maximizing human potential (founder and CEO of Shopify)

7Frameworks
16Insights

Episode overview

Shopify co-founder Tobi Lütke explains how dissatisfaction with the status quo fuels his leadership and first-principles product thinking. He argues that companies should remain data-informed without overfitting to metrics, preserving room for taste, quality, fun, and delight. The conversation also explores direct feedback, rapid course correction, long-term positive-sum partnerships, human potential, and Shopify’s century-scale mission to make entrepreneurship more common.

Key ideas

  • Compressing decision time is fairer than allowing people to keep working on a project that leadership believes will fail.
  • People remain far below their maximum potential, and candid feedback can help them pursue more ambitious work.
  • Metrics should support judgment rather than replace it; taste, quality, fun, and delight capture important unquantifiable value.
  • First-principles thinking means re-deriving foundational assumptions from today’s available building blocks instead of copying path-dependent solutions.
  • Leaders should welcome disagreement, locate the foundational assumption where views diverge, and change their minds when the facts change.
  • A long time horizon favors positive-sum relationships with customers and partners over pulling future profits forward at a discount.
  • Founders create finite, winnable games for teams that advance the company’s infinite mission and positional strength.
  • Great products require teams and product leaders who genuinely care, understand the details, and transmit energy to others.

Transcript available · source text is retained privately and is not published

Frameworks in this episode

People & resources mentioned

Attributed to the moment in the episode. Timestamps are approximate.

People · 13

  • Tobi LütkeMentionsif you look at Toby from Shopify, his scores aren't that good, but that company's doing really, really well.

    today my guest is Toby lka Toby is a man who needs no introduction

  • Lenny RachitskyMentionstoday we've got another very special compilation episode something I've been pulling on more and more with the podcast and the newsletter

    Toby thank you so much for being here welcome to the podcast

  • Elon MuskMentionsWhether you like him or not, Elon, this is similar to his um if you watch him, he has sets these really ambitious goals

    the most successful business person on plan at Earth is Elon

  • Glenn CoatesMentionsGlenn who's heads up core product

    I want to read a quote from Glenn coats he shared with me of how he sees you

  • Michael JordanMentionsMichael Jordan used to say that you know I've failed over and over and over and over again

    the last dance like a the the Netflix special of uh like Michael Jordan

  • Daniel WeinandMentionsI got a lot of founder energy for my co-founder Daniel

    I got a lot of founder energy for my co-founder Daniel

  • Harley FinkelsteinMentionsI'm a good friend with Harley Finkelstein, the president of Shopify

    Harley um so president is um on stage dejing

  • John Maynard KeynesCoinedmentioned

    when the facts change I change my opinion what do you do sir

  • Farhan ThawarMentionsfurhan is vice president and head of engineering at Shopify

    for Han your head of engineering asked them what's the best way to kind of get a glimpse into Toby's mind

  • James P. CarseCoinedmentioned

    James car did a incredible like under appre he wrote exent I think very accidentially wrote one of the best business books

  • Simon SinekMentionsAuthor of Start with Why

    I heard Simon simok wrote a book of a similar title

  • Brian ArmstrongMentionseventually I met folks like Naval ravikot and Sam Altman and Brian Armstrong and they recommended me around

    it reminds me something Brian Armstrong once shared

  • Kevin KellyCoinedYou mentioned Kevin Kelly's 1,000 True Fans, which has become this like canonical piece of writing on the internet now.

    there's a a 2005 essay by Kevin Kelly saying the like in the future on the internet you just need a thousand true fans

Resources · 32

  • SinchMentionscompany

    this episode is brought to you by cinch the customer Communications Cloud

  • Rich Communication Services (RCS)Mentionsproduct

    rich communication services or RCS think of RCs as SMS 2.0

  • FigmaMentionssoftware · Figma

    think AI co-pilots like notion multiplayer like figma comments and notifications like linear

  • Google DocsMentionssoftware · Google

    comments and notifications like linear and even collaborative editing like Google Docs

  • LinearMentionssoftware · Linear

    multiplayer like figma comments and notifications like linear and even collaborative editing like Google Docs

  • NotionMentionssoftware · Notion Labs

    think AI co-pilots like notion multiplayer like figma comments and notifications like linear

  • LiveblocksMentionscompany

    today's episode is brought to you by live blocks the platform that turns your product into a place that users want to be

  • ShopifyCoinedcompany · Shopify

    I didn't set out to build Shopify I build Shopify

  • The Last DanceUsesdocumentary · ESPN Films and Netflix

    I watched the last dance like a the the Netflix special of uh like Michael Jordan

  • NetflixMentionscompany · Netflix

    the Netflix special of uh like Michael Jordan

  • WikipediaMentionswebsite · Wikimedia Foundation

    I know Wikipedia word of Warcraft rating guilds have uh you know can at Le least have Excellence cultures

  • World of WarcraftMentionssoftware · Blizzard Entertainment

    I know Wikipedia word of Warcraft rating guilds have uh you know can at Le least have Excellence cultures

  • LoomMentionssoftware · Loom

    loom lets you record your screen your camera and your voice to share video messages

  • JiraMentionssoftware · Atlassian

    loom now part of atlassian the makers of jira

  • AtlassianMentionscompany

    loom now part of atlassian the makers of jira

  • CursorUsessoftware · Anysphere

    a view on my screen left of you is uh uh cursor right now

  • Jupyter NotebookUsessoftware · Project Jupyter

    which is opened to a um a juniper notebook where I'm um working on some projection stuff

  • StripeUsescompany · Patrick Collison and John Collison

    stripe and Shop F have had like a very long-term partnership

  • Finite and Infinite GamesRecommendsbook · James P. Carse

    I'm not going to take us here but I know you're a big fan of this book finite in infinite games

  • The Infinite GameMentionsbook · Simon Sinek

    I heard Simon simok wrote a book of a similar title

  • Stanford UniversityMentionsplace

    people always talk about W combinator and Stanford and all these places that create all these companies and Founders

  • Y CombinatorMentionscompany · Paul Graham and co-founders

    people always talk about W combinator and Stanford and all these places that create all these companies and Founders

  • TikTokMentionssoftware · ByteDance

    maybe Tik Tok has the same thing I don't know

  • InstagramUsessoftware · Meta

    I was posting a video to to to Instagram and um it allowed me to run a try run of of a reel

  • CoinbaseCoinedcompany · Brian Armstrong and Fred Ehrsam

    the reason that he uh he's also by way like you have to add him to the set of first principle thinkers

  • 1,000 True FansRecommendsother · Kevin Kelly

    there's a a 2005 essay by Kevin Kelly saying the like in the future on the internet you just need a thousand true fans

  • Pirate GoldRecommendsproduct

    I found this like pirate gold I think is called it's like just like amazing like poker set

  • Pirates of the CaribbeanMentionsfilm · The Walt Disney Company

    they come right out of the treasure chest or in Pires of Caribbean

  • RubyUsessoftware · Yukihiro Matsumoto

    we use Ruby Ruby was not that fast Shopify would rather have it very fast

  • Apple PodcastsMentionssoftware · Apple Inc.

    you can subscribe to the show on Apple podcasts Spotify or your favorite podcast app

  • SpotifyMentionssoftware · Spotify

    you can subscribe to the show on Apple podcasts Spotify or your favorite podcast app

  • LennyPodcast.comMentionswebsite · Lenny Rachitsky

    you can find all past episodes or learn more about the show at Lenny podcast.com

Spot an error or want something removed? Request a correction or removal.

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Hot Take· 4

Hot Take08:30

No One Is Even Close to Their Maximum Potential

Tobi argues that essentially nobody performs near their potential, and that reminding people of their own potential constantly is a wonderful thing to do. His hard, direct feedback is an attempt to hold people to their actual potential rather than their current level. He includes himself, saying he's harder on himself than on anyone else.

  • Most people are far better than they think; unambitious environments trap everyone competing on the same narrow things
  • He has a history of being right about people's potential more than they are themselves
  • Holding people to a high standard over long careers makes them accomplish things they didn't imagine they could
  • There is no speed limit for personal growth

there is not a single person on this planet who is even close to um uh being at their maximum potential

Tobi Lütke · 08:30

there is no speed limit for personal growth

Tobi Lütke · 11:30
#potential#feedback#growth#management
Hot Take17:30

Why Shopify Runs Without KPIs and OKRs

Tobi estimates that only about 20% of the most valuable product work is fully quantifiable, leaving 80% of the value space unaddressable to teams that only chase numbers. Shopify is extremely data-informed but deliberately avoids KPIs and OKRs so that unquantifiable things like taste, craft, fun and delight can be treated as first-class. He predicts that when people are having more fun, the metrics follow with a delay.

  • Roughly 20% of valuable product work is quantifiable; the other 80% is unaddressable by number-chasers
  • Shopify is data-informed with sophisticated hold-out and rollout systems, but data is a support function, not the boss
  • Fun and delight are treated as the most powerful business inputs
  • If fun rises while metrics fall, the metrics tend to follow upward after a delay; if not, they adjust course

the overlap of most valuable things you can do with a product and the things that happen to be fully quantifiable is like maybe 20%…

Tobi Lütke · 18:30

if all the metrics are pointing down but everyone says my God I'm having so much um more fun I think that the very next…

Tobi Lütke · 21:30
#metrics#product#culture#okrs
Hot Take22:30

The Alpha Is in the Unobvious-but-True

Tobi argues that aesthetics lead people astray: pessimism and metrics sound sophisticated while optimism and talk of fun sound naive. Because of that, almost all the alpha now sits in the unobvious-but-true things that people dismiss. He points to Elon as proof that the most successful business person conforms to none of the accepted ideas of what a sophisticated leader looks like.

  • There's an aesthetic (suits, charts, metrics-talk) that people wrongly equate with outperformance
  • Pessimism sounds sophisticated; optimism sounds dumb or naive
  • Almost all the alpha is now in unobvious-but-true ideas that others dismiss
  • Elon conforms to no idea of what a sophisticated business person should be

optimism always sounds dumb or at least naive

Tobi Lütke · 23:30

the most successful business person on plan at Earth is Elon and he conforms to no idea of what like the most sophisticated business person…

Tobi Lütke · 24:30
#contrarian#optimism#strategy#aesthetics
Hot Take1:25:30

Lower the "Courage Tax" With Try-Runs

Tobi was delighted by an Instagram feature that shows a reel to a few hundred out-of-network people before it posts to your profile, calling it a step-function upgrade to the A/B test. He generalizes: since the rarest thing in the world is courage, we should design products that lower the net amount of courage required. Pursuing ideas like this from first principles can unlock enormous value or reinvent an industry.

  • A "try-run" reel to out-of-network viewers is a more understandable upgrade to the traditional A/B test
  • Almost everything should have try-runs that run out of network
  • The rarest thing in the world is courage, not creativity or genius, so lower the courage needed
  • Chasing such ideas from first principles unfolds into incredible value

it allowed me to run a try run of of a reel

Tobi Lütke · 1:26:00

the rarest thing in the world is not even creative creativity or genius it's it's it's courage so let's lower the net amount of Courage…

Tobi Lütke · 1:27:00
#courage#product-ideas#first-principles#ux

Explainer· 5

Explainer14:00

Goodhart's Law Is Just Overfitting for Businesses

Tobi connects machine-learning overfitting to Goodhart's law: a model learns to cheat the benchmark just as a business degrades the moment a metric becomes a goal. He uses this to explain why schools optimize for marks (and why kids cheat) and why he distrusts single-metric optimization. Different fields reinvent the same enduring truth under different names.

  • Overfitting is a model learning to cheat the loss function, which only proxies the real task
  • Goodhart's law is literally the same thing applied to businesses
  • Any metric that becomes a goal ceases to be a good metric
  • Schools overfit to marks; the same universal truths recur across competitive fields under different names

goodarts law just says any metric that um becomes a goal ceases to be a a good metric

Tobi Lütke · 14:30

overfitting uh goodarts law are the same thing

Tobi Lütke · 15:00
#metrics#machine-learning#goodharts-law#strategy
Explainer29:00

Derive Every Product From First Principles

Tobi says every existing product is deeply path-dependent, encoding compromises that were true when it was built but no longer are. So a new product must be re-derived from the building blocks available right now, not copied from how others do it. Skipping that exercise and doing what everyone else does is, to him, an abdication of product leadership.

  • Everything that exists is highly path-dependent on assumptions that may no longer hold
  • Derive the solution from every building block available today, then decide whether to take shortcuts
  • Sometimes the status quo turns out to encode real wisdom, and you adopt it deliberately
  • Doing something world-class requires doing it differently; it's near-axiomatic

you have to derive it from first principles you have to say how would we solve this problem given every fun like building block that…

Tobi Lütke · 30:00

if you want to do something better than what exists you have to do it differently

Tobi Lütke · 31:30
#first-principles#product#innovation#strategy
Explainer1:05:30

Positive-Sum Games Are the Ultimate Growth Hack

Tobi frames business partnerships as an iterated prisoner's dilemma where coordinating over long horizons beats any momentary defection. He compares most companies to kids failing the marshmallow test, pulling future profits forward at a discount. Shopify's model is to add levers of monetization but not pull them, staying on the same side of the table as its customers.

  • The Stripe-Shopify partnership is iterated prisoner's dilemma played as coordinate, not defect
  • Most CEOs act like kids who grab the single marshmallow instead of waiting for two
  • His job is adding monetization levers to the room and then not pulling any of them
  • On a long enough timeline, positive-sum games with customers are the ultimate growth hack

being a good partner in business is like this sort of corporate marshmallow test

Tobi Lütke · 1:06:30

on a long enough timeline playing positive some games with your customers is the ultimate growth hack

1:09:30
#partnerships#long-term#prisoners-dilemma#monetization
Explainer1:10:00

Business Is a Positional Game, Not Just Tactics

Using chess, Tobi splits business into a positional game (territory, trust, role) and tactics (conversion, A/B tests). He argues the business world obsesses over tactics while the real, durable value lives in the positional game. Over-extracting via tactics drains the value you built positionally, which is how once-great companies fade.

  • Chess has two semi-independent games, positional and tactical; business only talks about tactics
  • You need enough tactical skill to not get margin-called, but that's not where the value is
  • The positional game is territory, trust, and how deeply merchants rely on you
  • Extracting the whole value through tactics leaves nothing in the tank and companies fade

the business world only talks about tactics it only talks about the conversion

Tobi Lütke · 1:10:30

if you do that you have nothing left in the tank and that's the companies that we all see that just sort of got to…

Tobi Lütke · 1:12:30
#strategy#chess#tactics#positioning
Explainer1:19:30

Every Time Software Gets Simpler, More Businesses Exist

Tobi argues that great UX taming complexity is almost a moral obligation, because bad software makes people feel dumb and can stop a fragile new entrepreneur in their tracks. Shopify's data shows that every time they make something simpler, more businesses exist on the platform. Autopiloting taxes, payments and fraud literally causes more entrepreneurship, which he calls the best answer to the most important question of his life.

  • Bad software makes people feel dumb, which he sees as an inversion of the human-tool hierarchy
  • Entrepreneurs are often unsophisticated, scared, and surrounded by naysayers, so one confusing moment can make them quit
  • Data shows every simplification leads to more businesses existing on the platform
  • Removing complexity (taxes, payments, fraud) actively causes more entrepreneurship

software goes bad it makes people feel dumb and machines do not get to negatively influence people

Tobi Lütke · 1:20:00

engaging in building something again is an is is an act of pure courage

Tobi Lütke · 1:21:00
#ux#entrepreneurship#simplicity#product

Story· 3

Story05:00

The "Toby Tornado": Why He Kills Projects Mid-Stream

Tobi describes the "Toby tornado" as compressing change, conflict and real talk into a very short time frame. When he sees a project heading the wrong way he ends it fast, and the team becomes the founders of the next version. He frames not intervening as an abdication of his founder responsibility he refuses to make.

  • The tornado is change management, conflict and real talk compressed into a very short time frame
  • When a project is killed, the people on it become the founders of the next version
  • If he's wrong it's vital he learns why; if he's right, letting people continue is unfair to them
  • Ignoring a bad direction would be an abdication of his CEO/founder responsibility

my lens is you realize we're just wasting time on this thing that is not going to work and we shouldn't do it

Tobi Lütke · 06:00

I'm either incorrect at which point this is super important that I understand why or I'm correct at which point it's super unfair for letting…

Tobi Lütke · 06:30
#leadership#decision-making#shopify#management
Story25:30

His Energy Source: Dissatisfaction and "Injecting Heat"

Tobi says companies default to room temperature and that founders are the ones who inject heat, letting a business outperform. Asked where his own energy comes from, he contrasts Michael Jordan's rivalry-and-insult fuel with his own: dissatisfaction with the status quo. He believes today is the dystopia of the future, so it behooves us to build toward progress.

  • Companies run at room temperature unless a founder injects heat; that's the only way to outperform
  • The best leaders are "exothermic" wellsprings of energy
  • Michael Jordan's energy source was rivalry and invented insults; Tobi's is dissatisfaction with the status quo
  • No one who really thinks about it would want to be born 20 years before today; today is the dystopia of the future

my energy source is dissatisfaction with stardus quo

Tobi Lütke · 28:00

I I think today is the dystopia of the future

Tobi Lütke · 28:30
#motivation#founders#energy#progress
Story38:00

How One Flipped Boolean Made Shopify Remote-Only

Tobi treats decisions like nested functions over foundational assumptions; when COVID flipped the basic Boolean "are people allowed to leave their house," the whole decision tree relocated to a far-off landing zone. He warns that reaching a bad local maximum by only making good choices is the most dangerous trap. Shopify's conclusion: don't port the office online, port the internet into the company.

  • Decisions are re-derived by rerunning the whole tree of foundational assumptions on updated information
  • When a base assumption flips, the same-quality decisions can land you somewhere completely different
  • You can reach a bad local maximum by only ever making good choices, which is the most dangerous case
  • Building a remote company is far harder, but pulling it off is a real achievement

most of the time you end up in a bad part of a tree in a bad in in a local Maxima of a path…

Tobi Lütke · 42:30

don't Port the office online let's Port the internet into a comp

Tobi Lütke · 44:30
#remote-work#decision-making#covid#path-dependence

Q&A· 2

Q&A46:00

Why a Public-Company CEO Still Codes

Told a story about him coding at a hackathon table with headphones in like any IC engineer, Tobi is surprised it's considered remarkable. Coding is his happy place and the job he actually always wanted but couldn't find. He argues that first-principles thinking starts from the atomic building blocks, so being close to the metal is essential to how he leads.

  • Coding is the job he actually wanted, one that didn't exist for him at a company
  • He apprenticed as a programmer in Germany at 16 and still keeps Cursor open to explore data
  • First-principles thinking starts from the atomic building blocks, the computers themselves
  • He deliberately doesn't conform to the traditional view of how a public-company CEO spends time

that is the jobs that exist for other people that's the job I actually want that's the one I couldn't find

Tobi Lütke · 47:00

it fits my brain like a glove

Tobi Lütke · 47:30
#coding#ceo#first-principles#craft
Q&A54:30

The Best Way to Disagree With Him: Just Do It

Asked the best way to disagree with him, Tobi says simply disagree; he craves it and trusts the person more because it takes courage. When someone pushes back he stops to find the unstated foundational assumption where they diverge. He argues courage is far rarer than IQ or genius, so he tries to make disagreement inviting and will even play devil's advocate against unanimous agreement.

  • Disagreement builds trust because it signals the person will do what's right over what's convenient
  • He hunts for the unstated foundational assumption that is the point of divergence
  • Courage is rarer than high IQ or even genius
  • He plays devil's advocate against too-predictable, unanimous proposals to force deeper argument

I think courage is really really rare

Tobi Lütke · 55:30

I found a lot more high IQ in indust than courage

Tobi Lütke · 55:30
#disagreement#courage#trust#culture

Takeaway· 2

Takeaway1:28:30

Treat Your Career Like a Product (The Talent Stack)

Tobi advises finding a rare intersection of a few things you're uniquely good at rather than competing for the top of one crowded field, echoing Kevin Kelly's "1,000 true fans." He illustrates with a pirate-themed poker set: enthusiasm is the best marketing, and it's better to make amazing things for some people than tolerable things for everyone. He reframes every career as entrepreneurship, selling yourself as a subscription of talent.

  • Win at a triplicate intersection of things you're uniquely strong at, not the crowded top of one field
  • Kevin Kelly's 2005 essay: on the internet you just need a thousand true fans
  • Enthusiasm is the best marketing; make amazing things for some people rather than tolerable things for everyone
  • Everyone is an entrepreneur; a career is talent-as-a-service, a double opt-in with a company

it's just better to make amazing things for some people than like make something that everyone wants maybe or would tolerate

Tobi Lütke · 1:34:00

we are all entrepreneurs so the way to think about any career if you actually ask me for career advice is um we are products

Tobi Lütke · 1:34:30
#career#talent-stack#entrepreneurship#niche
Takeaway1:37:00

Great Products Require People Who Give a Damn

Tobi's closing lesson: a product's quality is simply a reflection of how much the people who made it cared about it. Product leaders must make sure the team cares, both by building empathy for users and by being infectiously excited themselves. He ties this directly to "founder mode," which he understands as pumping heat into systems and protecting the people who do it.

  • Product quality is a direct reflection of how much the makers cared
  • You can't produce a great product working on something you don't care about
  • A product leader must build the team's empathy and be exothermically infectious about caring
  • "Founder mode" is pumping heat into systems, and founder-run companies protect the heat-pumpers so they can innovate longer

the quality at the end of the day is simply a reflection of how much the people who created it gave a [ __ ] about product

Tobi Lütke · 1:37:00

I answer the question about what I think about F mode in the discussion about pumping heat into systems

Tobi Lütke · 1:39:30
#product#founder-mode#leadership#craft