LLenny's Podcast
← All episodes
Eoghan McCabe (founder and CEO)21 August 2025

How Intercom rose from the ashes by betting everything on AI

5Frameworks
14Insights

Frameworks in this episode

Strategy4 steps

First-Principles Framework Method

Decompose every initiative into goal, mechanism, and value questions to build joined-up strategy — and mini-CEO operators.

Read →
Sales4 steps

Simpler-Fairer Pricing Reset

Deliberately give away revenue to simplify pricing — it lifts retention and restores a customer-obsessed culture.

Read →
Finance4 steps

Value-Anchored Outcome Pricing

Price the outcome, not the seat; set the number from customer value and let cost be your problem.

Read →
Leadership4 steps

Values as a Sharp Knife

Rewrite company values as deliberate filters, then hardcode a scoring formula that removes people who don't fit.

Read →
Leadership4 steps

Wartime Company Reset

When a platform shift threatens your core business, declare wartime and go all-in rather than hedge.

Read →

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Hot Take· 6

Hot Take12:30

Why an AI agent is more personal than a human

Intercom's founding mission was 'make internet business personal,' and McCabe wrestled with whether that survives an AI pivot. He argues it does: an instantly available, expert, consistent, friendly agent for every customer at every hour is more personal than making people wait days for a canned response. He concedes it may be post-rationalization but says AI is genuinely superior at the things we call personal and human.

  • Intercom's mission was 'make internet business personal'
  • McCabe questioned whether that mission still made sense with AI
  • An always-available, consistent, expert agent beats a multi-day canned reply
  • He argues AI can be superior at qualities we describe as personal and human

“so much more personal than making them wait two 3 4 days for a crappy canned response.”

Eoghan McCabe · 14:00

“it actually is superior at the things we describe as personal and human relative to humans themselves.”

Eoghan McCabe · 14:00
#ai#customer-service#philosophy#personalization
Hot Take15:00

AI is often superior — the Waymo case

McCabe uses Waymo to argue AI often beats humans on practical dimensions: it crashes far less, doesn't bug you, has no hygiene problems, and doesn't take wrong turns. He notes Uber now offers women female-only drivers because women feel safer in Waymos. He is pro-human for meaning and creativity, but wants AI and robotics for the practical, efficient 'glue' between the human parts of life.

  • Waymo crashes 3-5x less than humans, per McCabe
  • AI avoids human annoyances: hygiene issues, wrong turns, unwanted chat
  • Uber offering female-only drivers reflects women feeling safer in Waymos
  • McCabe wants humans for meaning, AI for practical, efficient value

“So, Whimo doesn't crash. It has 3 5 times less crashes than humans.”

Eoghan McCabe · 15:00

“women love Whimo because they feel safer.”

Eoghan McCabe · 15:30
#ai#waymo#automation#hot-take
Hot Take26:00

Founder mode: a soft coup, 40% turnover, 98% approval

McCabe describes taking an authoritarian, top-down approach: cutting costs, picking one lane (service), betting ~$100M of cash on AI, and rewriting the values as 'a sharp knife' to cut out ineffective parts of the company. He hardcoded a formula scoring people on both goals and value-behavior. It triggered a soft coup and letters to the board, ~40% turnover, but ended with a 98-99% approval of leadership and strategy.

  • Cut costs aggressively and killed projects while nearing negative growth
  • Picked one lane — service — over keeping an $80M ARR side business
  • Committed nearly $100M of Intercom's own cash to AI
  • Rewrote values as 'a sharp knife' and hardcoded a performance+behavior formula
  • Provoked a soft coup and ~40% turnover, but reached 98-99% leadership approval

“I rewrote the values designed to be a sharp knife to cut out the parts of the company that I just knew wouldn't be effective.”

Eoghan McCabe · 28:30

“it is the responsibility of the CEO to make brave and hard decisions unilaterally.”

Eoghan McCabe · 31:30
#founder-mode#leadership#culture#turnaround
Hot Take36:00

The unglamorous reality of being a CEO

Asked if he regretted returning, McCabe says never — it was cathartic — but he's honest that most days aren't the swashbuckling adventure people imagine. Success means reviewing bonus policy and comp proposals, accountability meetings, 8-10 meetings a day, and racing through emails so no one feels slighted. He calls corporate life something that 'kind of sucks,' especially for high-agency people like him, and stays only for a broader mission.

  • He never regretted returning; it was deeply cathartic after running away while sick
  • Most CEO days are bonus policy, comp proposals and accountability meetings, not bold moves
  • Rushing from meeting to meeting, 8-10 a day, isn't how he thinks life should be lived
  • He only stays because a broader mission makes it worthwhile

“It'll be rushing from meeting to meeting having 8 n 10 meetings a day. I don't happen to believe that that's a great way to…”

Eoghan McCabe · 38:00

“It's not it's corporate life kind of sucks, particularly for people like me.”

Eoghan McCabe · 38:30
#leadership#ceo#founder#reality
Hot Take45:30

Jobs will go — and it's the demeaning work that should

McCabe doesn't find job loss touchy: technology has always taken repetitive, demeaning, dangerous jobs, while population, GDP and longevity rose and crime fell. He points to the horror of a human clicking a macro to answer the same question all day, and to the bright spark in workers who'd flourish doing something else. He expects fewer people needed in CX and repetitive sales/SDR roles, mildly disagreeing with Marc Benioff.

  • Technology has always removed repetitive, demeaning, dangerous jobs
  • Historically, population, GDP and longevity rose while crime fell alongside that
  • Answering the same question all day by clicking a macro is a 'horrible use of a human life'
  • Expects fewer people in CX and repetitive sales/SDR roles
  • Slightly disagrees with Benioff, who said sales jobs aren't going away

“technology has done a really good job at stealing jobs that were repetitive, demeaning, dangerous.”

Eoghan McCabe · 45:30

“Like what a horrible use of a human life.”

Eoghan McCabe · 47:30
#ai#jobs#automation#future-of-work
Hot Take49:00

Why people will still pay more for humans

Even as AI aggregates and creates content, McCabe argues efficiency is not what humans value most — if it were, we'd always buy the cheapest of everything. People value beauty, human stories, heart and connection, and will pay more for an imperfect human like Lenny with his own take. The abundance of AI makes automated things worth zero, which is exactly why quality, craft, art and humanity command a premium.

  • Efficiency is not the top thing humans value — or we'd always buy the cheapest option
  • People value beauty, human stories, heart and connection
  • They'll pay more for an imperfect human with their own story and opinions
  • AI abundance drives the value of automated output toward zero
  • Quality, craft, art and humanity are what command a premium

“humans value things like beauty and human stories and human heart and connection.”

Eoghan McCabe · 49:30

“The abundance of AI is going to make automated things worth zero.”

Eoghan McCabe · 50:00
#ai#human-value#content#economics

Explainer· 2

Explainer23:00

The 99-cent bet: price on value, not cost

Finn charges 99 cents per resolved ticket — outcome-based pricing aligned to value delivered. McCabe explains that although research showed businesses spent $20-30 per ticket resolution, people simply won't value digital work as much as human work, so they landed on 99 cents as the nexus of maximum earnings and maximum palatability. Early on the cost was higher than the price, but he bet costs would fall — and they did.

  • Finn charges 99 cents per resolved customer ticket
  • Research showed many businesses spent $20-30 per ticket resolution
  • People undervalue digital work versus human work, even when it's better
  • Early on it cost more than 99 cents to resolve a ticket; McCabe bet costs would drop
  • His principle: pricing should come from value, not cost — cost is the company's problem

“if someone is not prepared to pay 99 cent for us to rapidly and elegantly, perfectly and excellently solve their customer's problem. We need to…”

Eoghan McCabe · 25:00

“I always believe that value should that pricing should come from value and not from cost. Cost is our problem.”

Eoghan McCabe · 25:00
#pricing#outcome-based-pricing#finn#unit-economics
Explainer1:04:30

Why Intercom produces so many top product leaders

Told that Intercom ranks number one for producing product leaders (alongside Palantir and Stripe), McCabe points to a deeply producty culture, a sprawling strategy that gave PMs mini-CEO autonomy, and a first-principles methodology where they built frameworks for everything. They also hired founder types — good founders, often not great employees — with a pitch to learn how great companies are built and then go start their own.

  • Intercom ranked number one for producing future product leaders, near Palantir and Stripe
  • A deeply producty culture attracted and retained strong product people
  • A sprawling strategy gave PMs real autonomy to act like mini-CEOs
  • A first-principles methodology meant building frameworks for everything (RICE, jobs-to-be-done)
  • They hired 'founder types' who were great founders but often not great long-term employees

“kind of the product of our big messy strategy was that we had PMs that got to act like mini CEOs.”

Eoghan McCabe · 1:06:00

“we would create frameworks for everything.”

Eoghan McCabe · 1:06:30
#product-management#culture#hiring#first-principles#intercom

Story· 4

Story05:30

Finn's growth: 1 to 12M ARR in year one, north of 300%

Eoghan McCabe lays out how well Intercom's AI agent Finn is performing. Intercom now ranks in the 15th percentile of ~120 public B2B software companies for ARR growth, and Finn itself is growing north of 300%, going from $1M to $12M ARR in its first year and heading past $100M ARR. In the customer-experience agent category, Intercom claims it is biggest by customer count and revenue and rated number one on G2.

  • Intercom sits in the 15th percentile of ~120 public B2B software companies for ARR growth
  • Finn is growing north of 300%
  • Finn grew from $1M to $12M ARR in its first year, now in solid mid-8-figure ARR
  • On track to pass $100M ARR with Finn in under three quarters
  • Claims biggest by customer count and revenue in the CX agent category, number one on G2

“The first year it grew from 1 to 12 million air or we're now in solid mid 8 or growth there.”

Eoghan McCabe · 06:00

“We win all our head-to-heads and our direct competitor bake offs. We're rated number one in G2.”

Eoghan McCabe · 06:30
#intercom#finn#ai-agents#growth#saas
Story07:30

Five quarters of decline and the pride that pulled him back

McCabe describes the state of Intercom before the AI pivot. After he left the CEO role in 2020 while sick with mold toxins and a tick-borne illness, the company grew bloated and unfocused, with revenue growth in the low single digits. Intercom saw five successive quarters of declining net new ARR and was about to hit zero, meaning negative growth. What pulled him back was pride and an unwillingness to watch the company fade.

  • McCabe left the CEO role in 2020 while sick with mold toxins and a later tick bite
  • The company became bloated, with a diluted, unfocused strategy
  • Revenue growth fell to the low single-digit percent
  • Five successive quarters of sequential decline in net new ARR, about to hit zero
  • Pride, not just the AI opportunity, drove his return

“we had five quarters of successive, you know, sequential decline in our net new error.”

Eoghan McCabe · 08:30

“still had a lot of pride for this damn thing and didn't want to see it end in a way that was so different from…”

Eoghan McCabe · 08:30
#intercom#turnaround#founder#decline#leadership
Story10:00

A Finn prototype in six weeks — and nothing to lose

McCabe credits luck: Intercom already had AI engineers and a customer-service ML team when GPT-3.5 launched. Just six weeks after launch they had a working beta of Finn, tapping a base of 30,000 paying customers and billions of data points. He is candid that the 'brave maverick' framing is partly retrospective — the company was in real trouble and had nothing to lose.

  • Intercom already had AI engineers and a customer-service ML team when GPT-3.5 launched
  • A working Finn beta existed just six weeks after GPT-3.5's launch
  • They had ~30,000 paying customers and billions of data points to work with
  • McCabe frames the bold move as partly born of desperation, not just courage

“he said the AI team have something interesting and they actually think we could make a product out of this”

Eoghan McCabe · 11:00

“I I don't know a a single company of our size and age that has pivoted this hard to AI and being as successful as…”

Eoghan McCabe · 11:30
#intercom#finn#gpt-3.5#product#pivot
Story58:00

Therapy, ego death, and becoming a better leader

Asked about a visible personal transformation, McCabe credits three things: 14 brutal years in a startup, 12 years of weekly therapy with a CEO-specialist coach (Yosi Amram), and a two-year period away, sick and attacked in the press, that eviscerated his ego. He argues great therapy smooths away only the counterproductive edges — the insecurity and triggers — and that the identity of being a perfect, brilliant leader had to die because it's so limiting.

  • Three sources: 14 years in a startup, 12 years of therapy, and two humbling years away
  • His coach Yosi Amram only worked with CEOs and helped him know himself
  • Good therapy removes only the counterproductive edges — insecurity, triggers
  • Understanding yourself lets you understand and communicate with others better
  • The ego-identity of being a perfect brilliant leader had to die because it's limiting

“the interesting thing about 12 years of weekly therapy and spiritual work is that it takes your edges off. But they are all edges that…”

Eoghan McCabe · 1:00:00

“your image that you are this perfect brilliant leader that all successful founders form when they are successful had to die.”

Eoghan McCabe · 1:01:30
#therapy#ego#personal-growth#leadership#founder

Takeaway· 2

Takeaway16:30

Giving away $50M in ARR to simplify pricing

Intercom's old pricing was infamous — a meme, mocked in viral tweets — because an unfocused 'all things for all people' strategy forced complex, multi-metric pricing. On his return, McCabe deliberately wrote down roughly $50M in ARR to give customers far simpler, fairer pricing, betting that predictability makes customers stay longer and builds a healthier relationship. He tied it to a new 'customer obsessed' value.

  • Intercom's old pricing was widely mocked, even in viral memes
  • An unfocused strategy forced complex multi-metric, multi-tier pricing
  • McCabe gave away roughly $50M in ARR to simplify and lower prices
  • Simpler, fairer, predictable pricing makes customers stick around longer
  • Complex unfair pricing eroded the internal belief that the company cared about customers

“we actually have already given away something like something like $50 million in AORA.”

Eoghan McCabe · 18:00

“when people feel like they have far simpler, more predictable, fairer pricing, they'll stick around longer”

Eoghan McCabe · 18:30
#pricing#strategy#saas#customer-obsession
Takeaway50:30

You don't have a choice — and if you can't, hire a kid

McCabe's core advice: with AI you don't have a choice, because it will disrupt every category in the most aggressive ways, and if you're not in it you'll be kicked out of all of it. Winning requires real AI talent (young and senior) and brutal hours — young AI companies work 12 hours a day, 365 days a year. If a previous-generation founder won't roll up their sleeves and work that hard, his blunt advice is to become chairperson and hire a kid.

  • AI will disrupt all categories, aggressively — 'you don't have a choice'
  • Bring in real AI scientists and leaders, plus young talent
  • Young AI companies work ~12 hours a day, 365 days a year, and vibe-code by default
  • Don't half-ass it by sprinkling a little AI onto the same culture
  • If you won't work that hard yourself, become chairperson and hire a kid

“if you're not in it, you're about to get kicked out of all of it.”

Eoghan McCabe · 51:30

“Hire a kid cuz you're in the wrong job, buddy.”

Eoghan McCabe · 53:30
#ai#advice#talent#disruption#hard-work