Nikhyl Singhal (Meta, Google)11 June 2023

Building a long and meaningful career

9Frameworks

15Insights

Episode overview

Nikhyl Singhal argues that people should design careers backward from a longer-term destination rather than optimize for the next promotion or prestigious company logo. He explains how early-career product managers can develop a distinctive strength and compelling career story, while managers must earn trust, share control, and learn through authentic communities. The conversation also examines stalled promotions, the growing senior individual-contributor path, the “shadows” cast by executive superpowers, and the need to develop a meaningful next North Star before conventional success becomes disorienting.

Key ideas

Treat a career like a product: work backward from a desired end state and plan for the job after the next one.
Avoid highly valued former-growth companies that are still searching for product-market fit unless the role offers bounded learning or loyalty value.
Early-career product managers should become world-class in at least one form of ambiguity or expertise and deliberately build a clear story about their impact.
Promotion stalls commonly reflect missing advocacy, the absence of a higher-level role, impatience, or an unresolved development area.
New managers should share the steering wheel, earn an invitation to help, and use trusted communities to learn skills their organizations may not teach.
Senior individual-contributor paths let strong builders deepen distinctive expertise without becoming underprepared managers.
An executive's superpower can create a hidden weakness at greater scale, so contradictory feedback should be examined rather than dismissed.
Long careers require a second North Star after conventional success, with giving, coaching, community, or mission-driven work offering meaningful act-three directions.

Transcript available · source text is retained privately and is not published

Frameworks in this episode

Strategy5 steps

Pick a Lane and Write the Story

Master one of the five product ambiguities early, then write the paragraph your next employer needs to hear.

Read →

Self-Mastery5 steps

Shadows of Superpowers

Your plateau is almost always the shadow cast by the exact strength that got you here.

Read →

Strategy5 steps

The Ex-Growth Company Test

Two questions that tell you whether your well-funded employer is quietly a dead-equity trap.

Read →

Leadership4 steps

The Four Reasons You're Not Getting Promoted

A diagnostic that separates 'the system can't promote you' from 'you're not ready' — because the fix differs.

Read →

Communication5 steps

The Ground-Truth Feedback Loop

Formal feedback is noise. Pull the real signal, prove you heard it, and publicly reward whoever gave it.

Read →

Productivity5 steps

The Meeting Operating System

Version your team's meetings like a product — ship a new rev every 90 days.

Read →

Leadership5 steps

The Sidecar Model of Management

You don't take the wheel or hand it over — you ride attached, and you have to be invited in first.

Read →

Strategy5 steps

The Skip: Career as a Product

Plan for the job after next, not the next job — and treat promotion as a means, not the goal.

Read →

Mindset5 steps

The Three Acts and the Next North Star

The greyhound that catches the rabbit never runs again — pick your second North Star before you catch the first.

Read →

People & resources mentioned

Attributed to the moment in the episode. Timestamps are approximate.

People · 7

Nikhyl SinghalMentionsnickel has worked on and led large teams on four different influential consumer products including Facebook Credit Karma Google Hangouts and Google photos
“today my guest is nikhail singall”
▶ Watch at ~1:00approx.
Lenny RachitskyMentionstoday we've got another very special compilation episode something I've been pulling on more and more with the podcast and the newsletter
“welcome to Lenny's podcast where I interview world-class product leaders and growth experts”
▶ Watch at ~1:00approx.
Geoffrey MooreCoinedJeffrey is the author of maybe the most influential and important book on go to market ever written crossing the chasm
“it's a book that Jeffrey Moore wrote”
▶ Watch at ~12:30approx.
Brian CheskyMentionsBrian chesky at Airbnb there was a whole article where we unpacked this moment in their product development cycle
“Brian is so big on you're not just Building Product your job is also to make sure people use it”
▶ Watch at ~14:30approx.
Josh MillerMentionstoday my guest is Josh Miller Josh is the CEO and co-founder of a company called the browser company
“we had Josh on the podcast we talked about a lot of their philosophies”
▶ Watch at ~18:30approx.
Jules WalterMentionsJules is a product leader at YouTube. Before that, he spent 4 and 1/2 years at Slack, where he was their first growth PM
“this reminds me of Jules Walters on the podcast he gave a bunch of advice”
▶ Watch at ~32:00approx.
Jules WalterMentionsJules is a product leader at YouTube. Before that, he spent 4 and 1/2 years at Slack, where he was their first growth PM
“I think Jules is a great probably one of the world's best people in pulling feedback in my experience”
▶ Watch at ~32:30approx.

Resources · 41

FacebookMentionscompany · Meta
“including Facebook Credit Karma Google Hangouts and Google photos”
▶ Watch at ~1:00approx.
Google PhotosMentionssoftware · Google
“including Facebook Credit Karma Google Hangouts and Google photos”
▶ Watch at ~1:00approx.
Lenny's PodcastCoinedpodcast · Lenny Rachitsky
“welcome to Lenny's podcast where I interview world-class product leaders and growth experts”
▶ Watch at ~1:00approx.
Google HangoutsMentionssoftware · Google
“including Facebook Credit Karma Google Hangouts and Google photos”
▶ Watch at ~1:00approx.
MetaMentionscompany
“currently he leads product teams for the Facebook app at meta”
▶ Watch at ~1:30approx.
Credit KarmaMentionscompany
“before that he served as Chief product officer at Credit Karma and held various leadership roles at Google”
▶ Watch at ~1:30approx.
GoogleMentionscompany · Google
“before that he served as Chief product officer at Credit Karma and held various leadership roles at Google”
▶ Watch at ~1:30approx.
SuperhumanMentionssoftware · Superhuman
“this episode is brought to you by superhuman”
▶ Watch at ~2:00approx.
Microsoft ClarityMentionstool · Microsoft
“this episode is brought to you by Microsoft Clarity a free easy to use tool”
▶ Watch at ~3:30approx.
Microsoft ClarityMentionstool · Microsoft
“check out Clarity at clarity.microsoft.com”
▶ Watch at ~4:30approx.
The SkipCoinedpodcast · Nikhyl Singhal
“the reason I called my newsletter my podcast the skip is because I always think about like what's not the next job”
▶ Watch at ~8:00approx.
UberMentionscompany · Uber
“working at Netflix and meta and Airbnb and Uber”
▶ Watch at ~10:30approx.
NetflixMentionscompany · Netflix
“working at Netflix and meta and Airbnb and Uber”
▶ Watch at ~10:30approx.
AirbnbMentionscompany · Brian Chesky, Joe Gebbia, and Nathan Blecharczyk
“working at Netflix and meta and Airbnb and Uber”
▶ Watch at ~10:30approx.
Crossing the ChasmRecommendsbook · Geoffrey Moore
“one is this sort of a little bit of an old school book called crossing the Chasm by Jeffrey Moore”
▶ Watch at ~12:30approx.
Leadership and Self-DeceptionRecommendsbook · The Arbinger Institute
“the second one is a book that none of your listeners have actually probably heard of called leadership and self-deception”
▶ Watch at ~13:00approx.
AdobeMentionscompany
“it also you know doesn't pay homage to Adobe and Salesforce and a number of other great companies”
▶ Watch at ~14:30approx.
SalesforceMentionscompany · Salesforce
“it also you know doesn't pay homage to Adobe and Salesforce and a number of other great companies”
▶ Watch at ~14:30approx.
RiseRecommendsfilm · Disney
“they have this Disney plus story called The Rise story”
▶ Watch at ~15:00approx.
DisneyMentionscompany · The Walt Disney Company
“they have this Disney plus story called The Rise story”
▶ Watch at ~15:00approx.
Google ChromeUsessoftware · Google
“I thought Chrome was pretty good”
▶ Watch at ~17:30approx.
Arc BrowserRecommendssoftware · The Browser Company
“the geeky answer in me is um is the arc browser”
▶ Watch at ~17:30approx.
Arc BrowserUsessoftware · The Browser Company
“also a huge fan it's all I use”
▶ Watch at ~18:30approx.
OpenAIMentionscompany
“so right now with open AI for example we're seeing ridiculous pull”
▶ Watch at ~20:30approx.
SpotifyMentionssoftware · Spotify
“is available on Apple and Spotify and others”
▶ Watch at ~23:00approx.
Apple PodcastsMentionssoftware · Apple Inc.
“is available on Apple and Spotify and others”
▶ Watch at ~23:00approx.
LinkedInUseswebsite · LinkedIn
“LinkedIn is is where I spend most of my time professionally”
▶ Watch at ~23:30approx.
The SkipCoinedpodcast · Nikhyl Singhal
“the other one is this sort of newsletter that I have on sub stack”
▶ Watch at ~23:30approx.
TwitterUseswebsite · Twitter
“between Twitter and Linkedin my presence is relatively easy to find”
▶ Watch at ~23:30approx.
SubstackUseswebsite · Substack Inc.
“the other one is this sort of newsletter that I have on sub stack”
▶ Watch at ~23:30approx.
AmazonMentionscompany · Jeff Bezos
“it's just like Amazon talks about building the press release before they start creating a product”
▶ Watch at ~24:30approx.
The SkipMentionspodcast · Nikhyl Singhal
“it's the skip.substack.com”
▶ Watch at ~25:00approx.
EppoMentionssoftware · Eppo
“this episode is brought to you by EPO EPO is a Next Generation a b testing platform built by Airbnb alums”
▶ Watch at ~44:00approx.
AirbnbUsescompany · Brian Chesky, Joe Gebbia, and Nathan Blecharczyk
“when I was at Airbnb one of the things that I loved most about working there was our experimentation platform”
▶ Watch at ~44:30approx.
EppoMentionssoftware · Eppo
“check out eppo.com”
▶ Watch at ~45:00approx.
ZoomUsessoftware · Zoom Video Communications
“how many great communities have slack channels or Discord channels or you know Zoom calls”
▶ Watch at ~46:30approx.
DiscordMentionssoftware · Discord Inc.
“how many great communities have slack channels or Discord channels or you know Zoom calls”
▶ Watch at ~46:30approx.
SlackUsessoftware · Slack Technologies
“how many great communities have slack channels or Discord channels or you know Zoom calls”
▶ Watch at ~46:30approx.
WhatsAppUsessoftware · Meta
“so we did a WhatsApp Channel and we brought a zoom call”
▶ Watch at ~49:00approx.
The Skip CPO CommunityCoinedother · Nikhyl Singhal
“there's a LinkedIn you know area called the skip CPO community”
▶ Watch at ~50:30approx.
Lenny's Newsletter CommunityCoinedother · Lenny Rachitsky
“if you're a paid subscriber to my newsletter there's a slack Community you get access to”
▶ Watch at ~51:30approx.

Spot an error or want something removed? Request a correction or removal.

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Hot Take· 4

Hot Take07:30

Stop Thinking Short-Term: Treat Your Career Like a Product

Nikhyl argues most people make career decisions on short-term irritations (bad boss, slow shipping) that exist at almost any company, so a lateral move solves nothing. Instead, work backwards from your end state and treat your career like a product with a v1, v2, v3. Plan for the job after next, not just the next role.

Complaints like 'I dislike my boss' exist at most jobs you'd move to
Lateral moves are by definition not forward moves
Work backwards from your end state; break the career into versions like a product
Optimize for your boss's boss's job, not just the next role

“lateral moves are by definition not forward moves”
Nikhyl Singhal · 08:00

“work backwards from your end State almost think of career as a product”
Nikhyl Singhal · 08:00

#career#long-term-thinking#product-mindset

Hot Take14:30

Ex-Growth Companies: The Danger Zone You Should Leave

Nikhyl warns about companies that raised huge rounds during zero-interest-rate blitzscaling, still have years of runway, but have quietly lost product-market fit. They keep hiring instead of laying off, so employees don't realize the equity is likely worthless. His blunt advice: this is the company to leave, not join.

ZIRP-era distribution let companies grow in 18 months what used to take 10 years
Well-capitalized ex-growth companies avoid layoffs and new rounds, so decline is hidden
Many public peers are worth 10% or less of prior valuations
Employees have almost no recourse; a reset is a fresh four-year investment

“danger this is not the company to join this is the company to leave find another phase times a wasting”
Nikhyl Singhal · 17:30

#ex-growth#startups#equity#career-risk

Hot Take35:00

Tech's Biggest Mistake: Never Training Its Managers

Nikhyl's strong take is that tech promoted great builders into management without training them, assuming skill at building implies skill at teaching others to build. He compares it to assuming a good car-maker knows how to build the factory, and calls the resulting problems an industry-wide epidemic.

Being a good coder doesn't make you ready to manage
Building skill and teaching-to-build skill are loosely coupled
The untrained-manager problem drives bias, poor coaching, and unaddressed development areas
Podcasts and community may now teach managers more than most L&D departments

“if you're a good coder you are ready to manage that's the way the industry works if you can talk you are ready to product…”
Nikhyl Singhal · 35:30

“if you can make a good car you must know how to make the factory that makes the car I don't think that's true at…”
Nikhyl Singhal · 36:00

#management#training#hot-take

Hot Take39:30

The Senior IC Path Is the Best Thing to Happen to Product

Nikhyl believes the rise of the senior IC track is one of the best things for the industry, correcting a long-standing bug where every product person was pushed into management. In hiring, he'd rather take an IC who deeply mastered a domain or market than someone who managed two people but let others do the details.

Growth-era incentives forced ICs into management to drive expansion
Engineering and design always had craft tracks; product wrongly made everyone a manager
A deep IC who mastered a hard market or org beats a shallow manager in hiring
The tracks are still 'tender' but will solidify within 6-9 months

“I think it is one of the best things to happen to our industry”
Nikhyl Singhal · 40:30

“I've been in ic for that whole time and during that time I went from learning something to demonstrating it to really being able to…”
Nikhyl Singhal · 41:30

#ic-track#career-paths#product-management

Explainer· 3

Explainer18:00

Two Questions to Tell If You're at an Ex-Growth Company

Nikhyl gives a simple diagnostic: ask whether you're scaling a product customers already love (a 'sucking sound' of demand) or still hunting for that pull. Then check whether your valuation is in the hundreds of millions. If you're still searching for demand but valued like a scaled company, you're at an ex-growth company.

Reframing the core product to find PMF implies a pre-PMF reality
Question 1: are we scaling love, or still looking for the customer 'sucking sound'?
Question 2: is the valuation hundreds of millions vs tens of millions?
Still searching + high valuation = ex-growth company

“are we scaling a product we have customers that love us and we have a tremendous sucking sound or are we trying to find that…”
Nikhyl Singhal · 18:30

“if the answer is hundreds or more and you're still trying to find that sucking sound you're an ex-growth company”
Nikhyl Singhal · 18:30

#product-market-fit#diagnostics#startups

Explainer25:30

The Four Real Reasons You're Not Getting Promoted

Nikhyl breaks down why people stall, noting managers often can't or won't tell you the real reason. The four causes: no advocate who sees your magic, no next role that actually exists (common after layoffs), impatience from high performers used to fast promotions, and a genuine development area you refuse to hear or change.

No advocacy: someone needs to see your 'magic' and champion it
The next role doesn't exist, especially post-layoffs and flattening
Impatience: top performers expect faster promotion than leadership can absorb
A real development area the person won't hear or won't change (about half of cases)

“the number one is that you just don't have advocacy you know you need someone to see the Magic”
Nikhyl Singhal · 26:00

#promotion#career#management

Explainer53:30

The Shadows of Superpowers: Why Top Leaders Plateau

A phrase from Nikhyl's therapist: every superpower casts a shadow no one examines. A world-class collaborator gets peer feedback that they're bad at collaboration, because they only collaborate when people agree with them. Great growth people struggle to innovate; storytellers miss details. The very strength that got you here becomes the development area blocking your next level.

What got you here isn't what gets you there; strengths must be rebuilt
A 'great collaborator' may only collaborate when others agree with them
Growth experts struggle to innovate; storytellers struggle with detail
Naming the shadow is hard because it sits inside the person's identity

“everyone focuses on your superpowers but no one ever thinks about what Shadows they create”
Nikhyl Singhal · 53:30

“you're collaborating as long as people agreed with your point of view”
Nikhyl Singhal · 54:30

#leadership#self-awareness#development

Story· 1

Story1:02:00

The Greyhound and the Rabbit: Why People Get Lost After Making It

Nikhyl tells of Midwest greyhound races where dogs chased a fake mechanical rabbit; if a dog ever caught it, it would never run again, having achieved the only thing it was wired for. He uses it to explain why successful leaders become lost and face mental-health struggles: they never planned a North Star beyond 'making it,' and act three of a 60-year career can be long and empty.

Careers now span 60+ years; act three is longer than ever before
People wire everything around one goal, then have nothing after achieving it
Success and being lost often go hand in hand
Start defining the next North Star before you arrive

“the moment that the dogs if they accidentally touched the rabbit they would never run again because there was like well what's next I've achieved…”
Nikhyl Singhal · 00:00

“otherwise you'll keep working because you know any nothing else to do but you'll be sadder or you'll find ways to create War when peace…”
Nikhyl Singhal · 1:06:00

#mental-health#purpose#long-term-career

Q&A· 1

Q&A1:15:30

His Favorite Interview Question: What Conventional Wisdom Is Hogwash?

Nikhyl's go-to interview question asks candidates what everyone takes for granted that they think is inaccurate. It's designed to break the rehearsed interview mindset, where candidates predict what the interviewer wants to hear, and instead test whether the person is genuinely, authentically opinionated.

Ask what conventional wisdom the candidate bets against and has found inaccurate
Rehearsed answers make interviewers dismiss genuinely high-quality people
The question can't be answered without being authentically opinionated
It's a test of authenticity, not just knowledge

“what's something that everyone takes for granted that you think is essentially hogwash or inaccurate”
Nikhyl Singhal · 1:15:30

“everyone always prepares for interviews and then their entire conversation is predicting what you think you want me to say”
Nikhyl Singhal · 1:16:30

#interviewing#hiring#authenticity

Takeaway· 6

Takeaway22:30

Early-Career PMs: Pick a Lane and Build a Story

For early-career product managers, Nikhyl's two priorities are to become world-class in one type of product ambiguity (market, organizational, domain, craft, or team) and to have a compelling story to tell the next employer. He invokes Amazon's press-release-first approach: define the story and skill you want, then let daily work serve it.

Types of ambiguity to master: market, organizational, domain, craft, team, growth
Goal 1: become an expert in at least one lane as early as possible
Goal 2: have a clear story of what you learned and did
Write the 'press release' of your story first, then work backwards

“picking a lane is kind of goal number one and then maybe goal number two is having a story to tell”
Nikhyl Singhal · 24:00

“it's just like Amazon talks about building the press release before they start”
Nikhyl Singhal · 24:30

#early-career#product-management#skill-building

Takeaway30:30

Why You Need Real Feedback, Not Formal Feedback

When you feel unseen, the fix is ground-truth feedback, not the formal review system, which Nikhyl says produces dramatically different (and softer) signal than honest peer conversations. The skill is pulling feedback: listen without justifying, triangulate across people, and create enough safety that people don't fear retaliation.

Formal feedback systems mask the real signal that peer conversations reveal
Don't justify or rebut feedback in the moment; that shuts people down
Triangulate from people who see you often and rarely
Create psychological safety so feedback flows without fear of retaliation

“you have to get real feedback not formal feedback”
Nikhyl Singhal · 30:30

#feedback#self-awareness#career

Takeaway37:00

New Managers: Be the Sidecar and Earn the Invitation

Nikhyl offers two metaphors for first-time managers. Management isn't divide-and-conquer or letting go of a bike; it's a sidecar on the motorcycle where the report drives and you give counsel. And organizational power doesn't grant real authority: like a vampire, you must be invited in before you can help, so start by asking how you can be useful.

Management is a sidecar, not divide-and-conquer or teaching-to-ride-a-bike
Org power isn't earned power; you must earn the right to manage someone
Ask what you can help with and wait to be invited in
Once invited, pick one or two areas and truly partner on them

“I think it's more like the sidecar on the motorcycle where persons on the driving the motorcycle and I'm on the side car and whether…”
Nikhyl Singhal · 37:30

“you're more like the vampire knocking on the door of someone you have to be invited in you just can't walk through the threshold”
Nikhyl Singhal · 38:30

#management#new-managers#leadership

Takeaway45:30

Community Is Where Real Learning Happens Now

Nikhyl argues structured corporate teaching is weak, and that community, inside or outside your company, is increasingly the answer for learning. Safe, authentic peer groups (Slack, Discord, Zoom) let people realize they aren't alone and share what actually works. He'd tell a stuck IC to invest in community over managing one random report.

Three learning modes: self-service tools, structured teaching (weak), and community (strongest)
Community creates safety, authenticity, and shared best practices
Social software has made great communities easy to run but hard to find
A demoted or stuck IC learns more from community than from managing one person

“there's this structured teaching which I think is weak and then there's community which I think whether it's within your company or outside of company…”
Nikhyl Singhal · 46:00

“learning isn't happening learning's happening in your community”
Nikhyl Singhal · 52:30

#community#learning#career

Takeaway1:08:30

The Two North Stars for Act Three: Scaled Economics or Giving

Nikhyl says later-career reinvention falls into two categories. One is scaling economics (millions to tens to hundreds), which pulls people from entrepreneurship to investing to private equity. The other is giving. He argues it's fine to take and create in acts one and two, but a giving-oriented act three is both more fulfilling and better for society.

Category 1: drive ever-larger scaled economics
Category 2: shift toward giving, echoing Eastern philosophies on happiness
It's okay to take and create in acts one and two
Equity provides the liberation to make act three about giving

“one categories are ways to drive more scaled economics I've made Millions my North Star is to now make it tens”
Nikhyl Singhal · 1:09:00

“if you're gonna work on an act 3 and you have 30 years regardless of where you are economically if you feel like you can…”
Nikhyl Singhal · 1:10:00

#north-star#purpose#later-career

Takeaway1:19:00

Run Your Meeting Operating System Like a Product

Nikhyl treats meetings as a product he re-versions every 90 days, currently on 'version 7.' At scale, the meeting operating system, how you organize meetings, attendees, decisions, and cadence, is as important as the products you ship, because meeting time is the most expensive time in a company. It's also the first thing a new leader can improve with fresh eyes.

Talk about meetings like a product with quarterly versions
Define meetings, attendees, decision-making, and cadence each 90 days
Meeting time is the most expensive time in a company
Reboot meetings first: process, then people, then product, then strategy

“the meeting operating system is as important as the products that we're building”
Nikhyl Singhal · 1:19:30

“I talk about our meetings like a product like we're on version 7 in my team”
Nikhyl Singhal · 1:20:00

#meetings#operations#leadership

Key ideas

Frameworks in this episode

Pick a Lane and Write the Story

Shadows of Superpowers

The Ex-Growth Company Test

The Four Reasons You're Not Getting Promoted

The Ground-Truth Feedback Loop

The Meeting Operating System

The Sidecar Model of Management

The Skip: Career as a Product

The Three Acts and the Next North Star

People & resources mentioned

People · 7

Resources · 41

Insights & moments

◆Hot Take· 4

Stop Thinking Short-Term: Treat Your Career Like a Product

Ex-Growth Companies: The Danger Zone You Should Leave

Tech's Biggest Mistake: Never Training Its Managers

The Senior IC Path Is the Best Thing to Happen to Product

✶Explainer· 3

Two Questions to Tell If You're at an Ex-Growth Company

The Four Real Reasons You're Not Getting Promoted

The Shadows of Superpowers: Why Top Leaders Plateau

❝Story· 1

The Greyhound and the Rabbit: Why People Get Lost After Making It

?Q&A· 1

His Favorite Interview Question: What Conventional Wisdom Is Hogwash?

▲Takeaway· 6

Early-Career PMs: Pick a Lane and Build a Story

Why You Need Real Feedback, Not Formal Feedback

New Managers: Be the Sidecar and Earn the Invitation

Community Is Where Real Learning Happens Now

The Two North Stars for Act Three: Scaled Economics or Giving

Run Your Meeting Operating System Like a Product

Hot Take· 4

Explainer· 3

Story· 1

Q&A· 1

Takeaway· 6